Top immigration court rules judges can deny bond to millions of immigrants
Los Angeles Times

Top immigration court rules judges can deny bond to millions of immigrants

A Trump administration policy to deny bond hearings to immigrants who entered the country without authorization was upheld by an immigration appellate board Friday, expanding mandatory detention to thousands of people already behind bars and potentially millions more nationwide. Although the policy is being challenged in federal court, the ruling by the Board of Immigration Appeals is likely ...

A Trump administration policy to deny bond hearings to immigrants who entered the country without authorization was upheld by an immigration appellate board Friday, expanding mandatory detention to thousands of people already behind bars and potentially millions more nationwide.

Dreamstime/Dreamstime/TNS


A Trump administration policy to deny bond hearings to immigrants who entered the country without authorization was upheld by an immigration appellate board Friday, expanding mandatory detention to thousands of people already behind bars and potentially millions more nationwide.

Although the policy is being challenged in federal court, the ruling by the Board of Immigration Appeals is likely to send an immediate chill through immigration courts where judges for decades have released individuals on bond whom they did not deem a flight risk or danger.

Those judges are now bound by the board's decision. Immigration courts are not part of the judicial branch but fall under the Department of Justice.

Immigrant rights attorneys say holding immigrants throughout their cases — a process that can sometimes take years — is intended to break the spirit of many and force them to sign their own deportation orders.

"This is an effort to increase the number of people in detention significantly," said Niels W. Frenzen, director of the USC Gould School of Law Immigration Clinic, who is part of a team of attorneys who have filed habeas petitions for dozens of immigrants picked up during the summer raids in Los Angeles.

"Literally millions of people are now subject to being held without bond," he said.

One of those is Ana Franco Galdamez, a mother of two U.S. citizens who has been in the country for two decades. She was getting treatment for breast cancer when she was arrested in a June 19 raid in Los Angeles County, where nearly 1 million undocumented immigrants reside, according to estimates.

She was denied bond and missed treatment, but she was eventually released after a lawyer filed a habeas case.

"Detention conditions are horrific, and they've gotten even worse," Frenzen said. "The goal of the administration is to make it difficult for people to fight their cases and to give up."

Federal judges have ruled in several cases that denying bond violated federal statutes and constitutionally protected due process. The group is now seeking to block the no-bond policy in a class-action lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. Other lawsuits are also pending.

The Trump administration introduced the no-bond policy nationally in a memo in July — paving the way for the mandatory detention of immigrants.

The move came after Congress authorized expanding immigration detention and enforcement amid a crackdown inside courtrooms and at immigration check-ins.

Immigrants, most of whom had been following the rules to adjust, maintain or gain legal status, were arrested and detained.

For months now, those inside the immigration courts system have been pressed to implement Trump administration policies. Judges have been fired, and the Pentagon has said it is identifying military lawyers and judges to temporarily sit on the bench.

The Department of Homeland Security did not respond to a request for comment. The Executive Office for Immigration Review, which oversees the immigration courts, did not answer specific questions from The Times — but pointed out that the ruling was a precedent.

"It strips judicial discretion in many cases," said Claire Trickler-McNulty, a former senior official with Immigration and Customs Enforcement. "It basically says, if you entered illegally, only ICE can decide if you get out of detention."

The Board of Immigration Appeals' decision stems from the case of a Venezuelan immigrant who crossed the border in November 2022 near El Paso, and was later granted temporary protected status. That status expired on April 2 after the Trump administration terminated the program, a decision that is also tied up in litigation.

The board determined that immigration judges had no authority to issue bonds because immigrants "who are present in the United States without admission ... must be detained for the duration of their removal proceedings."

In other words, the board's decision treats people who have been in the U.S. for years the same as newly arriving immigrants at the border, who can be quickly deported without bond.

"We've had clients that are pregnant, we've had clients that are breastfeeding. We've had clients who have never been arrested, let alone commit, convicted of any crime ever, who've never missed an ICE check-in — they're all being told, 'You're subject to mandatory detention because of this new interpretation by the Trump administration,'" said Jordan Wells, an attorney with the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area. "This now solidifies that as the law of the land, unless and until (the) federal circuit court rules otherwise."

_____

Recommended for You

'The Conjuring: Last Rites' creeps its way to another box office win for horror genre
AP News

'The Conjuring: Last Rites' creeps its way to another box office win for horror genre

News
A decades-long peace vigil outside the White House is dismantled after Trump's order
AP News

A decades-long peace vigil outside the White House is dismantled after Trump's order

News
Jayden Maiava leads USC offense to rout of Clay Helton's Georgia Southern team
Los Angeles Times

Jayden Maiava leads USC offense to rout of Clay Helton's Georgia Southern team

News
South Korea to charter plane for return of Hyundai factory workers
UPI

South Korea to charter plane for return of Hyundai factory workers

News
Court of Dreams gives people with disabilities an opportunity to play tennis at US Open
AP News

Court of Dreams gives people with disabilities an opportunity to play tennis at US Open

News
Georgia stuns France to reach EuroBasket quarterfinals, Slovenia and Poland also advance
AP News

Georgia stuns France to reach EuroBasket quarterfinals, Slovenia and Poland also advance

News
Vaccine chaos: Even some vulnerable seniors can't get COVID shots amid spiking cases
Los Angeles Times

Vaccine chaos: Even some vulnerable seniors can't get COVID shots amid spiking cases

News
OPEC+ to ease oil cuts, citing stable market outlook
UPI

OPEC+ to ease oil cuts, citing stable market outlook

News
No. 6 Oregon routs Oklahoma State 69-3 for Cowboys' biggest loss under Gundy
AP News

No. 6 Oregon routs Oklahoma State 69-3 for Cowboys' biggest loss under Gundy

News
Kyle Konrardy's late 54-yard field goal gives No. 16 Iowa State 16-13 win over Hawkeyes
AP News

Kyle Konrardy's late 54-yard field goal gives No. 16 Iowa State 16-13 win over Hawkeyes

News
'Life is Strange' to be adapted as Prime Video series
UPI

'Life is Strange' to be adapted as Prime Video series

News
Maryland leaders tell Trump they don't need the National Guard to curb gun violence
AP News

Maryland leaders tell Trump they don't need the National Guard to curb gun violence

News
Northwestern University president resigns amid funding fight with feds
UPI

Northwestern University president resigns amid funding fight with feds

News
LA judge who threatened to shoot people in his courtroom admonished by state panel
Los Angeles Times

LA judge who threatened to shoot people in his courtroom admonished by state panel

News
Jim Jarmusch, Ben Safdie take top honors at Venice Film Festival
UPI

Jim Jarmusch, Ben Safdie take top honors at Venice Film Festival

News