Trump's New York Times lawsuit dismissed by federal judge
UPI

Trump's New York Times lawsuit dismissed by federal judge

A $15 billion suit filed by President Donald Trump against the New York Times was rejected by a judge. He said the complaint had "superfluous allegations."

President Donald Trump speaks to the press before boarding Marine One earlier this week. A $15 billion suit filed by President Donald Trump against the New York Times was rejected by a judge on Friday. He said the complaint had “superfluous allegations.” Photo by Bonnie Cash/UPI UPI

Sept. 19 (UPI) -- A $15 billion lawsuit filed by President Donald Trump against the New York Times was rejected by a federal judge Friday.

Judge Steven Merryday in Tampa, Fla., said Trump's lengthy lawsuit had too much praise for the president and "superfluous allegations."

Merryday said Trump's two civil allegations against the newspaper are only mentioned in the last few pages of the 85-page complaint. The other pages are full of complaints about his political enemies and boasting of his accomplishments.

Merryday gave Trump 28 days to file another version of the lawsuit.

"As every lawyer knows (or is presumed to know), a complaint is not a public forum for vituperation and invective -- not a protected platform to rage against an adversary," Merryday wrote. "A complaint is not a megaphone for public relations or a podium for a passionate oration at a political rally or the functional equivalent of the Hyde Park Speakers' Corner."

"This action will begin, will continue, and will end in accord with the rules of procedure and in a professional and dignified manner," the judge wrote.

The Times company wrote in a statement when Trump's lawsuit was filed that his complaint is "without merit." Times executive editor Joe Kahn on Thursday said he was confident the paper would win.

"He's wrong on the facts; he's wrong on the law. And we'll fight it, and we'll win," Kahn said at an Axios Media Trends Live event Thursday. He said he did not see a scenario in which the Times would settle with the president.

When he filed the suit on Monday, Trump took to his Truth Social platform to accuse the newspaper of being a "virtual mouthpiece for the Radical Left Democratic Party," but did not give details of the alleged falsehoods.

The action for damages amounting to more than the full market capitalization of The New York Times Company, was, Trump said, motivated by an imperative to "restore integrity to journalism."

"The New York Times has been allowed to freely lie, smear, and defame me for far too long, and that stops, NOW!" Trump said.

He also criticized the paper's endorsement of Kamala Harris for president in the 2024 election.

Experts have said it was another instance of a strategy of using lawsuits of doubtful legality to gag critical voices and suppress free speech.

Trump has won multi-million dollar settlements from ABC News and CBS News, in December and July, respectively, prompting groups representing the journalism industry to warn that opting to settle out of court was only fueling Trump's "lawfare."

Addressing the Reporters & Editors 50th anniversary gala in New York on Monday, before the latest suit was filed, Times publisher AG Sulzberger warned of a growing so-called "anti-press playbook" trend among "aspiring strongmen" globally of leveraging civil law to exert financial pressure on media.

Recommended for You

Detectives try to retrace Celeste Rivas’ final days, collect evidence from D4vd’s Hollywood Hills home
Los Angeles Times

Detectives try to retrace Celeste Rivas’ final days, collect evidence from D4vd’s Hollywood Hills home

News
Trump to sign proclamation imposing $100K fee for H-1B visa applications, White House official says
AP News

Trump to sign proclamation imposing $100K fee for H-1B visa applications, White House official says

News
Trump appointee George Cook takes interim lead at Census Bureau amid new census push
AP News

Trump appointee George Cook takes interim lead at Census Bureau amid new census push

News
HBO Max to showcase 'It,' 'Knight of Seven Kingdoms' at NYCC
UPI

HBO Max to showcase 'It,' 'Knight of Seven Kingdoms' at NYCC

News
D4vd calls off Greek Theatre show amid police investigation
Los Angeles Times

D4vd calls off Greek Theatre show amid police investigation

News
McConaughey: 'Lost Bus' shows man-nature relationship out of balance
UPI

McConaughey: 'Lost Bus' shows man-nature relationship out of balance

News
Jair Bolsonaro hospitalized again in Brazil after coup conviction
UPI

Jair Bolsonaro hospitalized again in Brazil after coup conviction

News
Study: Brains of athletes could show signs of damage before CTE
UPI

Study: Brains of athletes could show signs of damage before CTE

News
Trump asks Supreme Court to uphold his firing of Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook
Los Angeles Times

Trump asks Supreme Court to uphold his firing of Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook

News
Starbucks workers sue over company's new dress code
AP News

Starbucks workers sue over company's new dress code

News
ABC’s decision to pull Jimmy Kimmel’s show has some echoes of network’s firing of Roseanne Barr
Los Angeles Times

ABC’s decision to pull Jimmy Kimmel’s show has some echoes of network’s firing of Roseanne Barr

News
Elected officials and dozens of protesters are arrested at Manhattan immigration holding facility
AP News

Elected officials and dozens of protesters are arrested at Manhattan immigration holding facility

News
LA Kings captain Anze Kopitar says he will retire after his upcoming 20th season
AP News

LA Kings captain Anze Kopitar says he will retire after his upcoming 20th season

News
Israel begins ground offensive in Gaza City with thousands of troops
Los Angeles Times

Israel begins ground offensive in Gaza City with thousands of troops

News
Texas man indicted for threatening NYC mayoral candidate Mamdani
UPI

Texas man indicted for threatening NYC mayoral candidate Mamdani

News